Subject: Re: OSI's war on corporate licenses
From: Rick Moen <>
Date: Mon, 11 Apr 2005 22:41:47 -0700

Quoting Mitchell Baker (

> I also find it odd that the community of people and projects that uses
> the MPL gets so little respect from OSI.  Many projects, both small
> and large use the MPL.  Many organizations, commerical or not, have
> reviewed the MPL and found it acceptable for their participation.  Why
> is OSI is such a hurry to diss it?   I would have thought that OSI
> would proceed very slowly and cautiously to label a diverse, content
> and productive community a failure. 

Indeed, I think you (somewhat in contrast to the post you were
responding to) make a good point, here.  As you suggest, there's nothing
inherently asymmetrical about the treatment of rights in MPL 1.0 or 1.1
-- and its per-module model has been innovative and useful.  

I hope the OSI statement's singling out MPL as "worthy experiment that
has failed" was a spur-of-the-moment thing and that the matter will be
further contemplated.