Subject: Re: OVPL Summary, Take 3
From: Ben Tilly <btilly@gmail.com>
Date: Sat, 17 Sep 2005 21:57:17 -0700

 Sat, 17 Sep 2005 21:57:17 -0700
On 9/17/05, David Barrett <dbarrett@quinthar.com> wrote:
> So my goal here is to create a summary that is reasonably accurate.  I'm
> not trying to generate more discussion, nor am I trying to highlight any
> more corner cases and fine details.  Rather, I'm hoping to get a general
> summary of the major points in a form most of us agree upon.  So if you
> see a flaw in the summary below, please don't respond with a broad
> discussion -- respond with specific textual changes.  Likewise, if
> something sounds unreasonable, please don't extrapolate it to its
> extreme conclusion and then debate that point -- guess what reasonable
> point I'm trying to make and then propose a clarification.
[...]
> D) The OVPL forbids "private groups", such as the GPL allows.
> 
> The rebuttal is that this is an OSD-compatible feature, not a bug.
[...]

The concern that I saw is that the OVPL allows the ID to go on
"fishing expeditions", making requests of people just to see what
you'll find.  I haven't been following closely enough to see whether
this has been addressed.  I'm also not entirely clear on whether this
is just a reason to dislike the license, or in some way is an
objection to its being approved.

If that is the concern that you are talking about in D), then I
personally am inclined to fall back on the definition that "a feature
is a bug with seniority" and note that this particular one isn't
senior, and so has not graduated to featuredom.

Cheers,
Ben