Subject: Re: Strong Court Ruling Upholds the Artistic License (fwd)
From: Matthew Flaschen <matthew.flaschen@gatech.edu>
Date: Sun, 17 Aug 2008 22:23:17 -0400

Tzeng, Nigel H. wrote:
> 1) He's an advocate for a certain position and not just a lawyer.  This
> position is somewhat similar but not identical to my own.  Therefore
> certain strategies are good for him but not necessarily good for me.
>  
> That's okay, of course, since he's not my lawyer.  Neither is he the
> lawyer for the OSF.
>  
> 2) In his profession, reality is whatever he can convince a judge to
> say is reality.  Therefore he can argue with complete sincerity and
> conviction that reality is X if he believes he has a strong enough
> case to have X upheld.
>  
> Even if !X can also be argued with complete sincerity and conviction
> by a different lawyer for the same reasons...

Indeed, it's important to remember that law is not logic.  Although, if 
the logical conclusion of law is too far from the /reasonable/ 
conclusion, laws need to be changed.

Matt Flaschen